Is renting really more affordable than buying in Utah’s housing market right now?

The answer might surprise you. National data shows buying is more affordable than renting in nearly 58% of U.S. counties, and depending on where you live in Utah, the math may be working more in your favor than you think.

Renting Feels Easier Until It Doesn’t

Renting often feels like the flexible choice.

No large down payment.
No long term commitment.
No surprise repair bills.

But then your rent increases. And then it increases again.

Suddenly, what felt flexible starts feeling expensive, especially when you realize you’re not building equity. You’re covering 100% of your housing cost each month, but none of it belongs to you.

In today’s Utah housing market, that reality is causing more renters to ask a smarter question:

“What would it actually cost me to own?”

The Data Behind Utah Housing Market Affordability

According to ATTOM, owning a home is more affordable than renting a 3 bedroom property in 57.7% of counties nationwide.

That calculation factors in:

• Mortgage payments

• Property taxes

• Homeowners insurance

• Typical maintenance costs

This isn’t just a surface level comparison. It’s a full monthly cost breakdown.

So what’s driving this shift?

• Slower home price growth compared to previous years

• More inventory hitting the market

• Mortgage rates easing from recent peaks

When you apply those national trends to the Utah housing market affordability conversation, the picture becomes more nuanced, but also more interesting.

What This Means for Buyers in Utah

Utah is part of the Western region, and nationally, the West still shows tighter affordability compared to the Midwest and South. In fact, only about 16.9% of Western counties show buying as more affordable than renting.

But here’s what that headline doesn’t tell you:

Real estate is hyper local.

Within Utah, affordability varies significantly depending on:

• Salt Lake County

• Utah County

• Davis County

• Weber County

• Washington County

• Smaller surrounding communities

Some areas have stabilized dramatically compared to peak pricing. Others are seeing improved inventory levels, which gives buyers more negotiating leverage than they’ve had in years.

In certain Utah neighborhoods, especially where rent has risen sharply, owning may now compete more closely with, or even beat, monthly rental costs.

The only way to know? Run the numbers locally.

Why Monthly Payments Aren’t the Whole Story?

When people talk about Utah housing market affordability, they usually focus on the mortgage payment alone.

But affordability isn’t just about this month.

It’s about:

• Equity growth over time

• Predictable housing costs

• Protection against rising rents

• Long-term financial positioning

With a fixed-rate mortgage, your principal and interest payment stays stable. Rent, on the other hand, can increase year after year.

Over five or ten years, that difference compounds.

While home values can move up or down in the short term, ownership creates a financial framework that renting simply doesn’t offer: the opportunity to build ownership instead of covering someone else’s investment.

The Real Obstacle: Upfront Costs

If you’re reading this and thinking:

“Okay, but I still can’t afford the down payment.”

You’re not alone.

For most renters in Utah, the biggest hurdle isn’t necessarily the monthly payment. It’s the upfront cash required to get started.

Here’s what many buyers don’t realize:

There are thousands of down payment assistance programs available nationwide, and many buyers qualify without knowing it.

The average benefit? Approximately $18,000.

In Utah specifically, there are state and local assistance options designed to help qualified buyers bridge that initial gap. These programs can be used toward:

• Down payments

• Closing costs

• Rate buydowns

That changes the equation significantly.

When you combine:

• Assistance options

• Moderating price growth

• Increased housing supply

• Easing interest rates

Buying may feel far more realistic than it did even a year ago.

Utah Housing Market Affordability Is Hyper-Local

This is where personalized strategy matters.

The national data tells us affordability is shifting.
The Western region shows tighter conditions overall.
Utah has experienced strong appreciation in recent years.

But within that broader picture, opportunities exist.

Some renters are currently paying:

• $2,200–$2,800+ per month for a 3-bedroom home

In certain Utah price ranges, ownership costs can fall into similar territory depending on:

• Purchase price

• Down payment

• Loan type

• Credit profile

The only responsible way to answer the affordability question is with a personalized breakdown, not a headline.

So, Should You Rush Out and Buy?

No.

That’s not the point.

The point is this:

Renting is not automatically the “safer” or more affordable option in today’s Utah housing market.

Buying is not automatically out of reach either.

Affordability isn’t determined by social media headlines.
It’s determined by math, specific to you.

Your income.
Your credit.
Your timeline.
Your goals.

What Smart Utah Renters Are Doing Right Now

Instead of assuming ownership is impossible, strategic renters are:

1. Getting a personalized affordability analysis

2. Exploring down payment assistance options

3. Comparing their current rent to real ownership numbers

4. Building a 12–24 month strategy if buying isn’t immediate

Even if buying isn’t right for you today, having a roadmap changes everything.

It moves you from “someday” to a defined plan.

Final Takeaway on Utah Housing Market Affordability

Nationally, buying is more affordable than renting in nearly 58% of counties.

The West remains more competitive, but Utah’s market is shifting.

Inventory has improved.
Price growth has cooled from peak levels.
Assistance programs exist.

The conversation is no longer “Can anyone afford to buy?”

The better question is:

“Does buying make sense for me in Utah right now?”

And that answer requires clarity, not guesswork.

Get a Personalized Affordability Breakdown

If you’re renting and feeling stuck in the loop of rising payments, the smartest next step isn’t commitment.

It’s information.

At The Lance Group Real Estate, we help Utah renters break down:

• What you could realistically afford

• What programs you may qualify for

• How your monthly payment would compare to your rent

• Whether now or later makes the most sense

No pressure. Just real numbers.

If you’d like a personalized affordability breakdown tailored to your situation and your part of the Utah housing market, reach out today. Let’s look at the math together.

Source: ATTOM 2025 Rental Affordability Report